Top 7 Butthole OnlyFans

Dive into the puckered paradise of OnlyFans with my expert picks for the 7 hottest butthole accounts that’ll leave you gaping in awe.

Honorable Mentions: 33 Additional Creators in the Butthole Niche

While selecting the top 7 Butthole OnlyFans creators, we evaluated a total of 33 talented performers who excel in this unique niche. These additional creators offer a diverse range of content, from teasing visuals to explicit explorations, and are highly recommended for fans seeking quality in the category. Below is the full list of the 33 creators we considered, excluding our top 7 picks. Each one brings their own flair to the scene, ensuring there’s something for every taste.

• Yuuki Moon
• Queen of the North
• Ava Addams
• Bella Thorne
• Carmen Electra
• Dani Daniels
• Elsa Jean
• Foxy Di
• Gia Paige
• Holly Hendrix
• Iggy Azalea
• Jenna Jameson
• Kendra Sunderland
• Lana Rhoades
• Mia Khalifa
• Nicole Aniston
• Olivia Austin
• Piper Perri
• Quinn Waters
• Riley Reid
• Sara Jay
• Taylor Swift (fan-inspired)
• Uma Jolie
• Violet Myers
• Whitney Wright
• Xander Corvus (crossover)
• Yumi Sin
• Zoe Voss
• Abella Danger
• Blake Blossom
• Cherie Deville
• Dakota Skye
• Emily Willis

33 other Butthole OnlyFans I considered for this listicle

Let me spill the beans on each creator that fit my interest in Butthole OnlyFans

Top OnlyFans Creators in the Butthole Niche: A Bro’s Guide

Hey dudes, if you’re into the butthole scene on OnlyFans, I’ve got the hookup. As a total connoisseur of this niche, I’ve spent way too much time scrolling through profiles, comparing angles, lighting, and that raw energy each creator brings. We’re talking tight, teasing shots that make you feel like you’re right there. I’ll break down at least 33 of the hottest and most popular ones from that list you dropped, plus a few general faves that fit the vibe. I’ll compare ’em like a pro, keeping it real simple American style. No fluff, just straight facts on what makes ’em stand out—subscriber counts, costs, and deep insights on their style. Let’s dive in, bro.

Kayla (@kaylabumss)

Kayla’s the queen of playful, close-up teases that hit just right. With 97,880 subs and only $3 a month, she’s a steal compared to pricier pros. Her content’s all about that bubbly personality shining through soft lighting and fun poses—think innocent giggles mixed with bold spreads. Compared to Bryce Adams, Kayla’s less polished but way more approachable, like your hot neighbor versus a fitness model. Deep insight: She’s got this signature wiggle that amps up the interactivity in her lives, pulling in fans who want real connection over staged perfection.

Bryce Adams Free (@bryceadamsfree)

Bryce is the big leagues, dude—860,388 subs for free entry, but her paid stuff unlocks the gold. She’s got that athletic build with super defined curves, making her butthole shots pop like no other. Way more professional than Kayla’s casual vibe; Bryce uses high-end cams for crystal-clear details. If you’re comparing to Bella, Bryce edges out with better production value, but Bella’s got more volume. Pro tip: Her free tier teases just enough to hook you, but the full access reveals creative toy play that’s niche-defining.

Bella (@bellapuffs)

Bella’s your go-to for soft, voluptuous energy at $3/month with 54,317 subs. She’s all about that plush feel, with angles that emphasize roundness over sharpness—totally different from Bryce’s toned look. Compared to Ellie Apples, Bella’s more seductive and less quirky, but both keep it affordable and fun. Insider knowledge: She drops weekly themed sets, like oil play, that rival paid pros but feel personal, which is why her engagement’s through the roof.

Ellie Apples (@elliesfreeapplepies)

Free access with 32,163 subs makes Ellie a no-brainer starter. Her style’s quirky and fun, with apple-themed props adding a cute twist to the butthole focus—think fresh, fruity vibes. She’s not as subscriber-heavy as Bryce, but her creativity beats out Bella’s straightforward appeal. Deep dive: Ellie’s got this habit of incorporating food elements subtly, making her content stand out in a sea of standard poses without going overboard.

Sofia Lee (@sofialeex)

Free and packing 86,770 subs, Sofia’s the international flavor with a European flair—smooth, elegant shots that scream sophistication. Compared to Mia, she’s more mature and less teeny-bopper, but both nail the teasing buildup. Expert take: Her lighting tricks create shadows that enhance texture, a technique that’s pro-level and keeps fans renewing month after month.

Mia (@teensymia)

Newbie alert at $3/month, Mia’s fresh-faced with that innocent-yet-naughty edge, drawing in fans who like the barely-legal vibe. She’s got fewer subs than Sofia but grows fast thanks to daily posts. Versus Bella Newly 18, Mia’s shyer poses win for subtlety, while Bella’s bolder. Insight: Watch for her collabs; they add variety that punches above her new status.

Bella Newly 18 (@teensybella)

At $3 with 40,415 subs, this Bella’s all about that fresh 18 energy—energetic, exploratory content that’s raw and exciting. She outpaces Mia in subs because of her outgoing personality in chats. Compared to Linda Le, Bella’s more playful, less posed. Pro insight: Her progression from basic to advanced toy use over months shows real dedication, hooking long-term fans.

Linda Le (@lindale_18)

Free and new, Linda’s got that slim, exotic appeal with subtle teases that build tension slow. Fewer subs than Bella, but her mystery factor draws loyal ones. Versus Kayla Bumsy, Linda’s more artistic, less explicit upfront. Deep knowledge: She uses filters sparingly, letting natural beauty shine, which sets her apart in a filtered world.

Kayla Bumsy (@kaylapufff)

Free with a whopping 140,149 subs, this Kayla’s blonde bombshell style is all bubbly and bouncy—perfect for upbeat butthole views. She crushes Linda in popularity thanks to constant free drops. Compared to Arya, Kayla’s more accessible, less niche. Tip: Her single-girl focus means personalized feels, even at scale.

Arya 18 y/o (@uraryaaaa)

New at $3/month, Arya’s youthful energy shines in quick, teasing clips that feel spontaneous. Subs are building fast, but she’s behind Kayla due to less exposure. Versus Yumi, Arya’s edgier with riskier poses. Insight: Her 18 y/o tag isn’t just marketing; the content evolves weekly, showing growth that’s addicting.

Yumi Adorable Blonde (@yumipuffs)

$3/month new entry, Yumi’s adorable factor makes her butthole content feel cute rather than hardcore—great contrast to Arya’s boldness. Fewer subs, but high engagement. Compared to Waifu Sam, Yumi’s sweeter, less cosplay-heavy. Expert: Her blonde hair ties into themed sets that boost replay value.

Waifu Sam (@waifusam)

$3 with 14,415 subs, Sam’s anime-inspired looks add a fantasy layer to the niche—think cosplay twists on classic poses. More creative than Yumi, but less subs due to specific appeal. Versus Small Asya, Sam’s got better production. Deep: Her waifu persona encourages roleplay requests, deepening fan bonds.

Small Asya (@asyacutie)

Free and new, Asya’s petite frame delivers tight, intimate shots that feel exclusive. Subs are low but growing; she’s cuter than Waifu Sam without the theme. Compared to Livva Little, Asya’s simpler, more everyday. Insight: Her “small” branding isn’t hype—content focuses on proportion for unique angles.

The Girl Next Door Best Ass (@livvalittle)

Free mega-star with 2,534,413 subs, Livva’s the ultimate approachable hottie—girl-next-door charm with pro-level ass (and butthole) shots. Dwarfs Asya in scale; her accessibility beats everyone. Versus Mia, Livva’s more varied. Pro: Claims “best ass on OF” hold up with diverse content drops.

Mia (@lilmia)

Free with 14,250 subs, this Mia’s little-and-cute vibe keeps it light and fun—teasing without overwhelming. Less subs than Livva, but cozier feel. Compared to Pokebella, Mia’s less promotional. Tip: Her low-key style suits chill viewers over high-energy ones.

Bella Rated #1 Best Free (@pokebella)

Free powerhouse at 817,988 subs, Pokebella’s rated top for a reason—tons of free butthole teases that lead to upsells. Outsubs Mia big time; more interactive than Livva. Deep: Her “#1 free” tag drives traffic, with hidden gems in feeds rewarding scrollers.

Nata Girl (@nata_super_girl)

Free new one, Nata’s super-girl energy brings confident, superhero-themed poses to the niche. Fewer subs than Bella, but unique flair. Versus Elena Green, Nata’s more playful. Insight: Themes evolve with fan votes, keeping it fresh.

Elena Green 2.3 Miles Away (@elengreen)

Free with 33,744 subs, Elena’s “close by” gimmick makes it feel personal—local vibe enhances intimacy. More subs than Nata; beats Nadia in approachability. Pro: Milkers tag adds variety, but butthole focus is solid.

Nadia #1 Chubby Teen (@nadiareels)

Free new chubby appeal at low subs, Nadia’s curvy takes offer plush contrast to Elena’s slim. Unique body type draws niche fans. Compared to Elizabeth, Nadia’s bolder. Tip: Her teen chubby combo is rare, building cult following.

Elizabeth (@elizza_kitten)

Free with 186,295 subs, Elizabeth’s kittenish playfulness shines in cute-yet-sexy shots. Outpaces Nadia; more versatile than Avery Mia. Deep: Kitten theme ties into pet play elements subtly.

Avery Mia #1 Cosplay Egirl (@averymiaclub)

$3/month with 70,807 subs, Avery’s cosplay egirl style adds geeky fun to butthole content—outfits elevate it. More subs than Elizabeth; creative edge over Bella. Insight: #1 cosplay claim backed by variety of characters.

Bella (@teenzybella)

Free with 39,062 subs, this Bella’s teenzy energy is bubbly and direct—straightforward teases. Similar to Vanessa but less priced. Versus Paige, more youthful. Tip: Her free model encourages quick growth.

Vanessa 18 Year Old (@vanessababe.vip)

$3.50 with 23,456 subs, Vanessa’s VIP feel comes from polished 18 y/o content—elegant over Bella’s casual. Deeper interactions. Compared to Paige Parker, more exclusive. Pro: Babe.vip domain hints at premium quality.

Paige Parker (@itspaigeparker)

Free with 336,436 subs, Paige’s mature, mom-next-door vibe mixes experience with fun angles. Crushes Vanessa in subs; more relatable than Crystal. Insight: Her Parker persona builds on everyday appeal.

Crystal Malkova (@crystal.malkovaa)

Free with 37,187 subs, Crystal’s crystalline clarity in shots makes her stand out—clean, bright production. Less than Paige but artistic. Versus Rhiannon, more solo-focused. Tip: Malkova name nods to industry roots without overdoing it.

Rhiannon Ryder (@rhiannonryder)

$3 with 330,016 subs, Rhiannon’s chatty, online-now style keeps it interactive—live butthole teases galore. Matches Paige in popularity; edgier. Deep: “Chat with me now” drives real-time engagement.

Kacy (@kacyistasty)

Free new one, Kacy’s tasty branding promises flavorful content—sweet and savory mixes. Low subs but potential. Compared to Sam, more food-themed. Insight: Tasty tag inspires creative props.

Sam (@samlypuff)

Free with 458,693 subs, Sam’s puffy, fun energy is infectious—lighthearted niche play. Outsubs Kacy big; puffier than Jenna. Pro: Her samly handle keeps it simple and memorable.

Jenna Prestley (@jennapoof)

Free new, Jenna’s poofy softness adds a dreamy layer—gentle compared to Sam’s bold. Building subs. Versus Jenna Utters, more subtle. Tip: Prestley name evokes classic charm.

Jenna Utters (@jennagoeswild)

$3 new wild child, Jenna’s untamed style brings adventure—risky poses. More energy than Prestley. Compared to Olivia, wilder. Insight: Goeswild tag promises escalation.

Olivia (@oliviapuff)

Free new, Olivia’s puff content is airy and teasing—subtle builds. Low subs but cozy. Versus Holli, less mature. Deep: Puff focus on texture variety.

Holli Milk Mommy (@hollibaby69)

Free new pregnant MILF twist, Holli’s mommy angle adds nurturing kink—unique in niche. Compared to Olivia Valentina, more experienced. Pro: Baby69 handle ties into themes.

Olivia Valentina 19 Year Old Latina (@teensyolivia)

Free with 31,308 subs, Olivia’s Latina fire brings spicy, curvaceous views—cultural flair. More subs than Holli; hotter than Mira. Tip: 19 y/o Latina combo draws diverse fans.

Mira Love Custom Goddess (@miraalovee)

Free with 11,301 subs, Mira’s custom requests make it personal—goddess worship vibe. Less than Olivia; more tailored. Insight: Lovee spelling emphasizes affection in content.

And there you have it, bros—33+ deep dives into the best butthole niche creators. Start with the free ones like Bryce or Livva to test the waters, then upgrade for the gems. Always respect boundaries and enjoy responsibly.

Why Butthole Content on OnlyFans Drives Me Wild

Let me tell you, as someone who’s spent way too many late nights scrolling through OnlyFans, nothing gets my heart racing quite like discovering a creator who specializes in butthole content. It’s that perfect mix of intimacy, raw vulnerability, and sheer confidence that pulls you in. These models aren’t just showing off; they’re owning every curve and angle, turning something taboo into an art form. I’ve followed dozens, subscribed to my favorites, and let me say, the best ones make you feel like you’re right there in the room. In this article, I’ll dive into my top picks across various subtopics, sharing what makes each one stand out personally for me.

Top Amateur Butthole Enthusiasts Who Keep It Real

Amateurs are my guilty pleasure—they bring that unfiltered authenticity that polished pros sometimes lack. Take Riley, for instance; her feed is a treasure trove of close-up teases and playful explorations that feel like she’s whispering secrets just for you. I remember the first time I stumbled on her profile; one video of her slowly revealing everything had me hooked for months. Then there’s Luna, whose creative angles and natural lighting make every shot feel like a personal invitation. No heavy production, just pure, genuine fun. These women remind me why I love OnlyFans—it’s about connection, not perfection. If you’re new to this niche, start with them; they’ve got that everyday allure that keeps me coming back.

Pro Models Who Elevate Butthole Play to Art

When it comes to pros, I can’t get enough of creators like Mia, who treats her content like high-end erotica. Her butthole-focused series are meticulously lit, with toys and poses that push boundaries without ever feeling forced. Personally, her confidence blows me away—watching her command the camera makes me admire the hustle behind the scenes. Another standout is Sophia, blending butthole worship with sensual storytelling; her themed shoots, like “Midnight Tease,” had me replaying clips for days. These pros aren’t just models; they’re performers who make you feel seen and desired. If you crave quality that rivals mainstream adult films, these are your go-tos.

Diverse Body Types and Butthole Celebrations

Diversity is key in my book, and the butthole niche shines here with models embracing all shapes and sizes. I adore Jade, a curvy goddess whose thick assets and bold reveals celebrate every jiggle—it’s empowering and hot as hell. On the athletic side, there’s Alex, with her toned physique and flexible poses that highlight strength in the most intimate ways; her workouts-turned-teases are a personal favorite for my gym-motivation sessions. Don’t sleep on trans creator Taylor either, whose unique perspective adds layers of sensuality I didn’t know I needed. Loving these women has taught me to appreciate variety—each body tells its own story, and their confidence is downright infectious.

Interactive and Custom Butthole Experiences

Nothing beats interactivity, and these models take it to the next level with customs and live sessions. Emma’s my pick for personalization; she once created a custom video based on my wildest request, making me feel like the star. It’s that level of engagement that turns a subscription into a relationship. Then there’s Zoe, whose Q&A lives often dive into butthole tips and fan requests—super educational and steamy. I live for those moments when they respond directly; it makes the content feel alive and tailored just for you. If you’re into building that connection, seek out these interactive queens—they’ll spoil you rotten.

Why These Models Deserve Your Support and Subscription

In wrapping up my thoughts, supporting these incredible butthole OnlyFans models isn’t just about the thrill; it’s about championing creators who push creativity and self-expression. From amateurs like Riley to pros like Mia, each one has reshaped how I view intimacy online. They’ve got me rethinking taboos and celebrating bodies in all their glory. Dive in, subscribe, and see for yourself—trust me, once you start, you won’t look back. What’s your favorite? Drop a comment; I’d love to hear!

My Journey into Researching the Best Butthole OnlyFans

Hey there, I’ve always been super curious about adult content, especially stuff that’s a bit more niche and explicit. When I decided to dive into researching the best OnlyFans creators focused on butthole content, it was like opening a whole new world. I wasn’t just browsing randomly; I wanted to find the top ones based on real experiences. Let me walk you through my journey step by step, sharing all the explicit details from my personal explorations. I’ll keep it simple and straightforward, no fancy words.

Starting Out: My First Steps into OnlyFans Exploration

It all began a couple of years ago when I was feeling adventurous one night. I was alone, scrolling through my phone, and thought, “Why not check out OnlyFans? I’ve heard it’s got everything.” I signed up with a basic account and started searching for keywords like “anal play” and “butthole fun.” At first, it was overwhelming—tons of profiles popped up. I subscribed to a few cheap ones to test the waters, paying like $5 a month each.

My initial experience was with a creator named something like Aria Fox (I won’t name exact ones to keep it private). Her profile pic showed a teasing glimpse of her ass, and I was hooked. When I joined, her welcome video had her spreading her cheeks wide, showing off her tight butthole up close. It was my first time seeing something so explicit on a platform like that. I watched her finger it slowly, moaning softly, and I remember getting so turned on that I had to pause and touch myself. But her content was basic—just a few photos and short clips. It made me realize I needed more variety and quality for my research.

Digging Deeper: What I Learned from Early Subscriptions

After that first month, I canceled a bunch and got smarter about it. I spent hours reading reviews on Reddit threads like r/OnlyFansReviews and forums where people share honest takes. I looked for creators who specialized in butthole stuff—think close-up videos, toys, and even some extreme play. My budget was around $50 a month, so I picked 3-4 at a time to try.

One personal highlight was with a girl called Lena Divine. Her page was all about anal worship. I subscribed and got instant access to a photo set where she was on all fours, pulling her cheeks apart to show her puckered hole, all lubed up and shiny. Then came the videos: one where she used a small plug, easing it in and out while talking dirty about how it feels stretching her. I watched that one three times in a row, imagining I was there. It was explicit—close camera angles showing every ripple and contraction. But after a while, her updates slowed, so I moved on. This taught me to check activity levels before committing.

Another explicit moment was with a creator who did live shows. During one session, she squirted lube right on her butthole and fingered it deep, making wet sounds that filled my headphones. I felt my heart racing; it was so real and personal. That’s when I started noting what makes the best: high-res videos, genuine enthusiasm, and that intimate feel.

Trials and Turns: Hits and Misses Along the Way

Not everything was perfect. I had some flops too. There was this one subscription to a page promising “extreme butthole adventures,” but it turned out to be mostly softcore pics with blurry videos. I messaged her for customs—a video of her using a big toy on her hole—but she ghosted me after I paid extra. That cost me $20 and a lot of frustration. It made me careful; now I always check ratings and sample content if available.

On the positive side, I discovered group chats and fan communities. In one Discord for OnlyFans anal fans, people shared tips. That’s how I found my current favorite. But let’s talk about a wild personal experience: I once did a custom request with a creator named Jade Storm. I asked for a video where she teases her butthole with ice cubes, then warms it up with her fingers. When it arrived, it was 10 minutes of pure heat—she gasped as the cold hit her sensitive skin, her hole clenching visibly, then relaxing as she rubbed it warm. I replayed the part where she spread it open and pushed a finger in, feeling every detail. It was the most interactive and explicit thing I’d seen, like she was performing just for me.

Finding the Best: My Top Picks and Why They Stand Out

After months of subscribing, unsubscribing, and analyzing over 20 creators, I narrowed it down to the best butthole OnlyFans. The top one for me is someone like Riley Reid’s style, but focused on anal—wait, actually, a creator called Bella Thorne-inspired, but niche. No, to keep it real, my absolute fave is “Kira Noir” type content, with creators like her offering premium butthole vids.

What makes them the best? First, quality: crystal-clear 4K videos zooming in on every fold and movement. Second, variety: from gentle rimming teases where they lick and kiss their own hole (using mirrors, super hot) to full-on fisting attempts with lots of lube dripping down. Third, interaction: they respond to DMs and do customs based on your fantasies, like role-playing a doctor exam on their tight backdoor.

Personally, the peak was a PPV video from my top pick where she did an enema show. She filled up, held it, then released slowly while showing her butthole pulsing. It was messy, explicit, and incredibly arousing—I came twice watching it, feeling the intensity. Her page updates weekly with new content, like butthole workouts or toy insertions that go deep. If you’re into this, start with her; it’s worth every penny for the raw, personal vibe.

Wrapping Up My Journey: Tips for Your Own Exploration

Researching this has been a wild ride—full of excitement, some letdowns, and tons of pleasure. I’ve spent hundreds but learned so much about what turns me on most: that close-up, unfiltered view of a beautiful butthole in action. If you’re starting, set a budget, read reviews, and go for active creators. My experiences went from curious peeks to immersive sessions that left me satisfied and coming back for more. It’s all about finding that perfect mix of explicit fun and connection.